Friday, April 22, 2022

Saints: Boldly, Nobly, and Independent (1893-1955) – The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints – 4 Stars

 

Saints: Boldly, Nobly, and Independent (1893-1955) – The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints – 4 Stars

Title: Saints: Boldly, Nobly, and Independent

Author: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Publisher: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Year: Softcover 2022

Rating: 4 Stars

 

Price and Purchasing Options: Similar to other volumes and editions in this project, it is a mass-produced softcover that should be available at any local LDS Book Store, Seagull Book, or Deseret Book.   The book should be less than $10 in physical format, and within a month or two I would suspect to start seeing it in Deseret Industries and secondhand stores for cheaper. This is also available through the LDS Distribution Site for order.  The text is available on the LDS Library App for reading and audible listening (both are recommended forms) – and the text is available online at www.churchofjesuschrist.org. 

 

Review: This book is probably one of the better pieces of work the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has ever done.  It is probably one of the best books and content that will never really be read or appreciated – due to the fact that is covers a period of time often ignored for the perception of less than sensational content.  If there is anything that I could do as a reviewer of LDS books, that might encourage you to actually get and read this book, or even listen it – I should.

This book sits cushioned in a time often ignored within the church (post-manifesto through the mid-twentieth century).  It is not the foundations of the restoration, or the building of the kingdom in the west.  The grand images of Joseph Smith and Brigham Young are long gone from the narrative, and we find ourselves with a succession of Prophets navigating the church through some unusual time.  But it is a time that is foundational to what we enjoy today – and it is a time of faith promoting (and honest) challenges.  The world has changed within this time and is changing at a rapid speed with church debt, war, and navigating growing the church through global conflicts.

It is a time of unusual revelation, that again we take for granted, not recognizing the impact that those moments have on us today.

Most importantly, in addition to highlighting a critically overlooked period within the history of the Church, it highlights this time beyond just the facts and the figures.  It highlights them through the very real struggles that real people have – the political challenges of navigating a church within a larger national ecosystem with different political views within the upper governing bodies of the church itself, the continuation of some practices of polygamy after the original manifesto, and the prophetic navigation of the congressional interviews in order to help seat an elected representative.

This book follows the hallmark of the previous books, with an honest approach -  one that will not highlight the doings or creates additional commentary – but one that doesn’t shy away from addressing the realities of the doings and challenges of the church at this time.  If there was an issue at this time that is ever challengeable it is presented factually in the text (however, it will not be addressed comprehensively). 

The authors and collaborators have also done a remarkable job of making the history readable and relatable.  Rather than reading like a history book, with dates and facts, if helps connect those dates and facts to the lives of the people that are experiencing them.  It reads like an actual book, which I suspect will be extremely appreciated by most readers.  It was on of the easiest, fastest, and smoothest books I have read in a long time.

It is highly encouraged that all members of the church read this text.  I give it four stars, because it is the best book for the topic and the period of time it covers pretty succinctly and comprehensively, while building faith through relatable narratives.

 


Suggestion: Pick it up!

Review # 57

Monday, March 4, 2019

Saints: The Standard of Truth (1815-1846) – The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints - 4 Stars

Saints: The Standard of Truth (1815-1846) – The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints -  4 Stars

Title: Saints: The Standard of Truth (1815-1846)
Author: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Publisher: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Year: Softcover 2018

Rating:  4 Stars

Price and Purchasing Options:  This is a mass softcover publication by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and is readily available for just above the printing price – around $5 directly from them.  As such, this can be ordered online, through the Church or purchased at any Deseret Book.  It also is available on audio file for listening, as well as through digital format on lds.org, or LDS App.

Review: This book is more important to the church than just the content. It has been over 100 years since The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has had a comprehensive history published.

Previous to this book BH Roberts project of synthesizing and editing the journals and history of the church, which was eventually published as the 7 volume series, as The History of the Church, was the only project like this.  That project, has since been identified as having some editorial reflections that have been problematic for many historians.  In addition, as the source material was somewhat autobiographical, it was much less a comprehensive history, and more of a singular perspective on history. 

Since the publication of that history, so much more has been learned regarding the events of the church, much of which have been identified, and acknowledged only within the last few decades.

One reason why the importance of this book transcends the context, is that over the last few decades the church has been under some scrutiny for not having a more comprehensive dialogue regarding some historical moments in the church.

What this text does, is remarkably weave together multiple narratives together to help identify and stitch together many of these events.  It includes stories that previously had not been publically acknowledged or published by the Church, and touches (although loosely) on just about every single unique or challengeable topic that has been addressed in it’s history over the last few decades. 

Some criticism that has been highlighted, is that these topics are not comprehensively addressed – however, it is clear it is not a comprehensive work.  It is a wonderfully comprehensively concise work on the history of the church – and nothing more – but that is so much more than the members of the church have had before. 

With that being said, this is a 4 star book.  Although, it will not help you be a better Christian, it will give you a greater understanding and perspective on the history of the church.  It is a remarkably well done work, straddling critical issues in the right context to give information and inoculate members to challenging topics, within a safe environment.

I would highly recommend this text to anyone and everyone, as a foundational text to understanding the history of the restoration.

Suggestions:  Pick it up!

I hope you have enjoyed this review, and I encourage you to follow this blog as I update more reviews in the coming days, weeks, months, etc.  Please feel free to also follow my YouTube page – however, I enjoy writing more than being on camera! PLEASE CLICK ON THE VIDEO BELOW AND SUBSCRIBE TO MY LDS BOOK REVIEWS' YouTube CHANNEL!



Review #56

Tags: 4 Stars, Ryan Daley, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Saints: The Standard of Truth, Church History, Joseph

Saturday, February 23, 2019

Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith – Tom M. Compton – 3 Stars

Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith – Tom M. Compton – 3 Stars

Title: Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith

Author: Tom M. Compton
Publisher: Signature Books
Year: Hardcover 1997

Rating:  3 Stars

Price and Purchasing Options: This is best found on Amazon.  You are not prone to find this at any Deseret Book, or Deseret Industries – and you may find it second hand on Ebay.

Review: This is an interesting book, that takes an interesting approach.

The concept of this book is brief, but well written, biographical summaries on the various wives of Joseph Smith.  They way it is executed is actually what I love about the book, but also what makes me question its value in the LDS Community.  So although I appreciated it, only a small niche in the community would appreciate it.

The irony is as much as the unifying theme between these women is plural marriage, the content itself doesn’t address it outside of it being a part (to some a small part, and to others a life long endeavor) of their lives.  Each “chapter” really covers in earnest one woman, and who she was before, during, and after their engagement in plural marriage to Joseph Smith. 

I appreciate how the author gives each woman her own space, making this much more about the person rather than the principle.  As you can imagine, this is not a “faithful” text, but nor is it either a “faithless” text – but allows the female experience of each of them address the topic itself – and focuses more on who the woman was, rather than on the principle itself; because these women were not defined by this principle, although that is what they primarily will be remembered by.

So were faithful to the succession leadership of the church, and some were not – some stayed, and some left; some found peace in the principle, and some found chaos in it.  But it is aptly titled, as all found a sense of loneliness in the principle. 

I feel like Compton treated each individually fairly in this biographical sketch, and covered more than just their life as it would apply to their involvement in the church.  It was well researched, and a worthy work to be printed – and it also covers both those wives which were sealed during his life, and those which were sealed after his death (which were not chosen by Smith, but by the women themselves, and performed by his successors post mortem).

I personally applaud the text, and think it is the best book on these women for those who are curious – but it will not add much context to the discussion regarding plural marriage, but it will help you appreciate the diversity in experiences of how this particular group of women experienced it.

Suggestions:  Pick it up if you are curious and enjoy biographical sketches.

I hope you have enjoyed this review, and I encourage you to follow this blog as I update more reviews in the coming days, weeks, months, etc.  Please feel free to also follow my YouTube page – however, I enjoy writing more than being on camera! PLEASE CLICK ON THE VIDEO BELOW AND SUBSCRIBE TO MY LDS BOOK REVIEWS' YouTube CHANNEL!



Review #55


Tags: 3 Stars, Ryan Daley, Tom M Compton, Sacred Loneliness, Church History, Joseph Smith, Polygamy

Saturday, August 25, 2018

An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins – Grant H. Palmer – 1 Star

An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins – Grant H. Palmer – 1 Star

Title: An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins
Author: Grant H. Palmer
Publisher: Signature Books
Year: Softcover (Originally) 2002



Rating:  1 Stars

Price and Purchasing Options: You will not see this in many second hand stores, and it will not be in LDS Book Stores.  Your best bet is eBay or Amazon.  I don’t recommend getting this book regardless of price… so buying it shouldn’t matter.

Review: This is the worst book on Mormonism I have ever read for a number of reason.

First, the level of deception attempted in the naming and marketing of this book is ridiculous.  Grant Palmer, classifies himself as an insider having been in the Church Education System for a significant amount of time. In classifying himself as an insider, and outlining his background in the church, many members could look at the book as a thoughtful and thoroughly researched outline of the challenges regarding the origins of the church – a worthy endeavors for anyone in the church education system that long. 

However, what this book actually is, is a list of challenges to the origins of Mormonism, with absolutely no effort at all to resolve to discuss it – besides just presenting the worst possible views of them.  He will bring up everything from the translation of the plates, the book of Abraham, the Kinderhook plates, and polygamy; but never once will he actually try to discuss the topic to resolution. 

It becomes clear really fast, that somewhere he lost his faith, that his faith became his job, and that was it – and when his job was over, he wrote this book to outline why nothing makes sense.  He loses credibility very quickly when the passive student in Mormonism can resolve many of what he projects as conflict, and observes that Palmer doesn’t even attempt or insinuate this is a resolve for the conflict.

This book serves no purpose but to deceive members of the Church into thinking it can be a resource, for these challenges, but ultimately just adds fuel to the fires of doubt without any reasonable dialogue. 

I honestly have never been more upset at a book, it’s intention, or its content in my entire life.  It was offensive more on its level of deception than on its actual content.

I give this 1 Star because it is not only worth avoiding in it’s entirely, but it is worth taking these books and throwing them away.  If you see one at Deseret Industries or a second hand store – pick it up for a buck, and then throw it in the trash on your way out.

Suggestions:  DON’T BUY THIS BOOK EVER!

I hope you have enjoyed this review, and I encourage you to follow this blog as I update more reviews in the coming days, weeks, months, etc.  Please feel free to also follow my YouTube page – however, I enjoy writing more than being on camera! PLEASE CLICK ON THE VIDEO BELOW AND SUBSCRIBE TO MY LDS BOOK REVIEWS' YouTube CHANNEL!


Review #54


Tags: 1 Stars, Ryan Daley, Grant H. Palmer, An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins, Church History